I loved these songs and also the hymns we sang in our little church, located right in the middle of our village in Einlage, Neuland Colony, Paraguay. I clearly recall singing at the top of my lungs one day when my mother told me I should stop singing because I didn't know how to sing properly. She was probably annoyed because there was always a lot of racket with seven noisy children swarming around her while she was longing for some peace and quiet.
But the message I understood was that I couldn't sing.
I believed it because mothers know everything (at least that is what you think when you are a small child!).
As a result of my mother's criticism, I decided that if I couldn't sing I would do other things and I would do them very well. And so I became an overachiever and a person desperately afraid of failure. I worried what people would think of me and that they would judge me unless I was perfect. I always received accolades and compliments for poems I memorized and recited on church holidays such as at Easter and Christmas. I had no stage fright until we came to Canada and I discovered I spoke with an accent.
People at church were not accustomed to long recitations in German and, sensitive as I was to failure, I could feel them mocking me. Later on, in high school, I had problems with geometry. My mathematics teacher was one who loved to call his students to the board and ridicule them when they failed to understand what he was asking them to do. At the time I didn't realize that it was he who was a failure as a teacher and not I as a student!
Failure is a feeling long before it becomes an actual result. It's vulnerability that breeds self-doubt and then is escalated, often deliberately, by fear, writes Michelle Obama in her book Becoming: A Guided Journal for Discovering Your Voice (based on her best selling memoir Becoming).
I did sing in church choirs as a young person, always making sure to stand beside my friends Donna or Katie who had strong alto voices, as I did not think I could harmonize on my own.
Just recently, in one of her sermons, our middle daughter talked about all the music we had in our home when she and her siblings were growing up. "Someone was always singing or playing an instrument or listening to music," she noted.
It surprised me, in a pleasant sort of way, because I have never considered myself musical although I love to sing. I found my voice again as a young mother. My mother's songs all came back to me. Babies who needed soothing did not criticize. Their father, Hardy, also loves to sing and often played his mouth organ. Our oldest is a natural songbird and when her teacher told me she had perfect pitch, something inside me glowed. The three siblings often sang together. I have a distinct memory of a fellow missionary "auntie" teaching them Peace is Flowing like a River and how much they loved singing it. During home leaves, they sang in the churches we visited. When my mother heard them singing, she was moved to tears. For me this was an unexpected and loving gift from God.


I just finished reading my blogger friend Marian Beaman's memoir Mennonite Daughter: The Story of a Plain Girl. Without bitterness or malice, she shares about some very painful things that happened to her at the hands of people close to her who should have supported rather than punished her. We all make mistakes, even with the best intentions. And there is forgiveness. And there is healing in telling our story.
Michelle Obama again: If you don't see that your story matters, chances are no one else will either. So even though it isn't always easy, it's important for you to find the strength to share your truth, because the world needs to hear it.


Enjoyed this post about your singing (or not, for a while) and your girls singing. Interesting what our kids remember of us...
ReplyDeleteYes, it’s usually a surprise to the parents.I’m sure my mom doesn’t remember saying that to me about my. Singing!
ReplyDeleteAhh the words we say to our kids and to other people too, often having no idea the effect those words can have - good or bad.
ReplyDeleteMakes one wonder what we have said inadvertently that has hurt our loved ones. I think I was a very sensitive child ...”Nu es se aul wada beleidigt” (now her feelings are hurt again) is something I heard frequently said about me. That didn’t help matters either.
ReplyDeleteWow, Elfrieda, what a pleasant surprise: My book sharing space with Michelle Obama's. Thanks for the kind words. Yes, I write out of victory, not malice. Your story is similar to mine but with different characters. And now you understand who is the one with the problem. A choice line from your post: "At the time I didn't realize that it was he who was a failure as a teacher and not I as a student!"
ReplyDeleteMy mother sang gospel songs in the kitchen probably because that was her happy place. Also, I remember Grandma Longenecker holding me in her lap and singing a German lullaby. The only words I can remember from her song was "kind" and "schlaf." But I remember how she made me feel. :-)
Thank you for all this; you have given me a boost today, Elfrieda!
Marian, I read your book not long after I heard Michelle Obama give a speech here in Winnipeg and then read her book and bought the accompanying journal. She too writes very openly about her family life, very similar to what we know, where the aunt lives downstairs and gives her piano lessons and also some sharp reprimands!
DeleteI think I know the song your Grandma sang. Perhaps it’s “Schlaf’ Kindlein schlaf/ Der Vater huetet die Schaf” (Sleep little child sleep/ your father guards the sheep”. Maybe if you google that line you can listen to it. My mother sang that one too!
Thanks, Elfrieda.
Delete"There is healing in telling our story." I find this to be so true. Thank you for sharing this glimpse of yours!
ReplyDeleteYou’re welcome, Kathy. Thanks for reading and commenting!
ReplyDeleteIf only we could sing ourselves through life...how much healthier mentally we would be! Music is such a beautiful way to express feelings and emotions....whether you have pitch or not! We carry our mother'S words with us and interpret as we feel them.
ReplyDeleteSo happy you have lots of music in your life Elfrieda
Yes, it’s been my saving grace especially in troublesome times!
ReplyDelete